David Luiz. A Defensive Liability?

David Luiz: A defensive Liability?
David Luiz: A defensive Liability?

The famous Sky Sports pundit Jamie Redknapp has labelled David Luiz as a “defensive liability” due to a somewhat moderate performance in the match against Everton. Here we will try to analyse this statement about arguably the fans most favorite player in the current Chelsea squad.

When he joined Chelsea from Benfica in 2011 for an undisclosed fee, Luiz probably was a bit raw still with alot of potential but not living up to that. His attacking instincts sometimes got the better of him which cost the team some goals and inevitably some valuable points . But like a thorough professional that he always has been , Luiz kept on improving under the watchful eye of world beaters like John Terry and Ashley Cole. His rise has been nothing short of amazing and his attitude towards the game has always been exemplary

Commonly known as “GEEZER” among the fans , Luiz has since helped the team to a number of crucial victories plus some more silverware to add to our ever growing collection. Lets take the example of the most famous night in the history of CFC i.e 19th May 2012. A Champions League Final. Luiz was totally up for it .There were some suggestions that he was not completely fit but he felt the responsibility on his shoulders in the absence of his Captain JT and rose up to the task at hand. It takes balls to nullify the attack of Bayern Munich in their own backyard and Luiz did that quite consistently for 120 Minutes. Its hard enough for a fully fit defender let alone for a half-fit ‘liability’. But the fairy tale didn’t end there. There was a small matter of a penalty shoot out and Juan Mata having missed the first spot kick, All eyes were on Luiz to score his.. and Man how easily did he do that.. That takes nerves of steel and the determination of a warrior .. All of which are attributes we can relate to David Luiz.

Now coming to the attacking mindset he has, its no surprise that he has scored some screamers in his time with the blues. and who doesn’t love that? Be it the amazing volley against united or the free kick against FC Norjselland. The 35 yard bullet against Fulham or the curler against Steaua Bucharest.. I don’t remember any defender in the modern game scoring that quality of goals. There is no denying that he like to bombard forward and control the game but the maturity comes with time and still only 26, Luiz is yet to reach his prime as a defender in my opinion and he is one guy we should net let go at any cost due to this very fact that his best years are yet to come.

One of the Best Goal Line Clearances by David Luiz vs Spain in the Confederations Cup Final

There was a reason why Barcelona were chasing Luiz all along the transfer window. and mind you it was for the CB position. (One for you Mr. Redknapp). There are some ridiculous suggestions that because of his light hearted attitude and fun antics off the field, he is not focused on his game. Maybe they should see the Confederations Cup final highlights and see that out-of-the-world goal line clearance of Pedro’s shot. That Ladies and Gentleman is Luiz for you.


To sum it all up, we should not judge our players on the basis of one or two bad performances. Defenders and Mistakes are a common combination. David Luiz certainly has more positives to add to the team being a liability. and let me answer this in some simple accounting language that Mr Redknapp can understand.

“David Luiz was maybe a LIABILITY, but now he is one FIXED ASSET.”

Keep the Blue Flag Flying High!

  1. Ishola Benjamin Kunle says

    Too early to Judge the Best defender in Epl and champions league winner. He kept proving them wrong.

  2. Abeer Khan says

    😀 Great Article

  3. Nasir (@FCA90) says

    Great piece mate. He has both positives and the negatives. He needs to add an element of calmness to his game. He is an aggressive player who likes to be involved in the game every time and in doing so he sometimes act recklessly. Overall, we have seen great improvement in his performances during his time here and he is a great asset for Chelsea and Brazil.

  4. Anonymous says

    The amazing part is GEEZER and usually GEEZER works well in Winter..

  5. Sanam says

    “David Luiz was maybe a LIABILITY, but now he is one FIXED ASSET.”

    i understand this so well 😛

  6. areeba says

    Nice and informative… Highlighted each n every aspect of his life… 🙂

  7. Hani says

    must admit I find it insightful to read your blogging. Keep up the good work.

  8. Anonymous says

    He lacks positioning,and he should seat back n defend not try to do d work of a midfielder..I prefer gary cahill to him,maturity,threat in d air n positions well.

  9. abdulshakuruh says

    luiz is the best defender in this bussiness today

  10. luke says

    let him ask Nivelle he wil tell him much abt Luiz

  11. kashif says

    nice article

    1. River says

      Very valid, pithy, suticncc, and on point. WD.

  12. Moiz says

    Nicely written and clasically summed up..

  13. Anonymous says

    i agrre with u totally man

  14. Waqas Mir says

    Nice Man. I like it 😀

  15. Shiloh says

    Jamie Reddnap isn’t 1 to write or comment carelessly on a football matter, he made a point in that article that Luiz lack possition and was too eager to go forward. Luiz is a fantatics player but sometimes i think he should just concerntrate on his defending and allow the strikers and midfielders to do the creating and scoring of goals.

  16. Ola says

    His a good player nd is what chelsea want but let him stay in is defend nd he shoul play 4 chelsea the way he play 4 brazil ok thanks 4 the article

  17. Irokotola michael says

    that man says the truth about him, he should try to check himself, noone is envying him. A defender is meant to defend not attack, can’t him learn from RC6.(ricaldo calvaho). You make a good and mature calculation of the ball before you attack and not the one that will fire back on the team. He should try and make amendment and continue to play as he did against bayern in that final. Noone will blame him.

  18. Vaakmeisster says

    Luiz just needs to focus more. But he will neverbe a Chielini or Carvalho, JT and Terry are similar players. Both have lapses of concentration, JT has learnt from experience to recover quickly after a mistake, Luiz hasn’t. I don’t think Luiz- Terry is a good combination, Terry – Cahill or Luiz- Cahill is more stable as Cahill is a calming influence.

  19. carlos figueira says

    best defensive midfielder in the world. everyone here including mourinho seem to forget. with cahill and jt why we need david skills, passing and scoring ability in defense? is every one mad in here?

  20. Hello, i think that i saw you visited my weblog thus i came to “return
    the favor”.I am attempting to find things to improve
    my site!I suppose its ok to use some of your ideas!!


Comments are closed.